The Californian’s radio operator, Cyril Evans, shut his radio
off at 11:30 PM after being told to “Shut up!” Therefore, he could not receive
the subsequent SOS calls nearby.
(Captain Stanley Lord, commanding the SS Californian, ordered the ship to a
full stop for the night to avoid collision with an iceberg.)
1 in 20
Spotting of iceberg by lookouts in the crow’s nest was too late
to avoid a collision, but early enough (37 seconds) to commence evasive
maneuver which compounded damage beyond survivability - a 230-foot-long tear in
the Titanic’s hull, flooding six separate compartments (Four flooded would not
have sunk her.) Had the lookouts been posted on the bow, forty feet lower, they
might have seen the outline of the iceberg against the faint horizon sooner.
The ship’s searchlight should have been lit to illuminate the path ahead, even
though it was not standard procedure. It was, after all, a moonless night with
no waves washing against ice floes.
1 in 10
Watch officer throwing all engines in reverse while ordering the
helm hard a-port, robbing the rudder of the authority it had while running. (If
instead he had reversed only the port engine, leaving the center and starboard
engines in forward, or if he had reversed all engines while maintaining the
original track, the Titanic might not have sustained fatal damage. A direct hit
surely would not have flooded all six compartments.)
1 in 20
Inexcusable failure of Captain Edwards or any officers to
oversee filling all 20 lifeboats, 4 of which were collapsible, to rated
capacity, much less to some arbitrary but reasonable number over theoretical
capacity (say ten more people) in view of the exceptionally calm seas
1 in 50
Failure of Captain Lord, of the SS Californian, twenty miles
north, and in sight, to react immediately to distress flares reported to him by
his crew (He didn’t even bother to summon his radioman to call the Titanic and
inquire if there was an emergency.)
1 in 50
The compound probability of all successive events multiplied
together is one
chance in 1.25 x 10 to the 34th power.
I did not set out with a goal of some particular probability of
the Titanic sinking. I simply made my own reasonable estimate of each
successive dependent factor. Make different estimates of your own if you wish.
Using your own estimates will give you a better idea of how unlikely the entire
series of events was.
Each of the above factors is arguably on the critical path to
the sinking and incredible loss of life. The Titanic might well have survived
the collision if not missed the iceberg entirely, or alternatively, all 1,514
passengers lost might have been saved through the elimination of just one of
the foregoing events, each of which contributed to the catastrophe. It is
noteworthy that there was, on average, 20 empty seats in each of the 20
lifeboats launched. Moreover, an average of 12 crewmen occupied each lifeboat,
when only 2 were needed to operate it. Therefore the crewmen put their own
lives and safety ahead of their passengers, for whom they were responsible.
[Note on the nature of estimating probabilities: I have had many
discussions on the topic of estimating probabilities on the subject of the
marvelous, profoundly improbable nature of life and the universe around us, and
the obvious, pervasive hand of our Creator. Almost unfailingly, atheists make
the absurd contention that if something happened, then the probability that it would happen was
1. (Because it happened.) The chance of you drawing the three of clubs randomly
from a shuffled deck of cards is 1 in 52 before the event. Whether or not you
actually did draw the three of clubs, the chances of drawing it were still 1 in 52.
Estimating probability is how we measure uncertainty, or likelihood, for an
event or an event series.]
______________________________________
Six Chinese passengers survived the sinking, but they were immediately turned away under the Chinese Exclusion Act. Under the 1882 federal law, Chinese immigrants were barred from entering the US.
Famous people who missed the boat
J. Pierpont Morgan
The legendary 74-year-old financier, nicknamed the "Napoleon of Wall Street," had helped create General Electric and U.S. Steel and was credited with almost singlehandedly saving the U.S. banking system during the Panic of 1907.
Among his varied business interests was the International Mercantile Marine, the shipping combine that controlled Britain's White Star Line, owner of the Titanic. Morgan attended the ship's launching in 1911 and had a personal suite on board with his own promenade deck and a bath equipped with specially designed cigar holders. He was reportedly booked on the maiden voyage but instead remained at the French resort of Aix to enjoy his morning massages and sulfur baths.
Milton Snavely Hershey
The man
behind the Hershey's Milk Chocolate Bar, Hershey's Kisses, Hershey's Syrup, and
the Pennsylvania city that bears his name had spent the winter in France and
planned to sail home on the Titanic. The Hershey Community Archives has
in its collection a $300 check Hershey wrote to the White Star Line in December
1911, believed to be a 10 percent deposit toward his stateroom, according to
archivist Tammy L. Hamilton. Fortunately for Hershey, business back home
apparently intervened, and he and his wife instead caught a ship that was
sailing earlier, the German liner Amerika. The Amerika would earn
its own footnote in the disaster, as one of several ships to send the Titanic
warnings of ice in its path.
Although Marconi was later grilled by a Senate committee over allegations that his company’s wireless operators had withheld news from the public in order to sell information to the New York Times, he emerged from the disaster as one of its heroes, his invention credited with saving more than 700 lives.
:focal(281x184:282x185)/https://tf-cmsv2-smithsonianmag-media.s3.amazonaws.com/filer/Titanic-Missed-the-Boat-Henry-Clay-Frick-5.jpg)
Henry Clay Frick
The Pittsburgh steel baron was a business associate of fellow non-passenger J.P. Morgan. He canceled his passage on the Titanic when his wife sprained her ankle and had to be hospitalized in Italy.
:focal(234x199:235x200)/https://tf-cmsv2-smithsonianmag-media.s3.amazonaws.com/filer/Titanic-Missed-the-Boat-Alfred-Gwynne-Vanderbilt-6.jpg)
Alfred Gwynne Vanderbilt
The 34-year-old multimillionaire sportsman, an heir to the Vanderbilt shipping and railroad empire, was returning from a trip to Europe and canceled his passage on the Titanic so late that some early newspaper accounts listed him as being on board. Vanderbilt lived on to become one the most celebrated casualties of the Lusitania sinking three years later.



Comments
Post a Comment